I can’t say enough about the high-quality, professional care at New View Eye Center. Dr. Griffiths and her staff are caring, thorough, and provide excellent service. I feel fortunate to have her as my ophthalmologist.
Mary D.
ICL Candidacy: Who Qualifies for Implantable Collamer Lenses
Vision Prescription Requirements
ICLs are designed primarily for patients with significant nearsightedness, and the prescription requirements are quite specific. Understanding where your prescription falls on the spectrum helps set realistic expectations before your evaluation.
ICLs work best for moderate to severe nearsightedness, generally ranging from about minus 3.00 to minus 18.00 diopters (a unit of measurement for lens power). If your prescription is stronger than minus 8.00 or minus 10.00, ICL may actually be a better option than LASIK, since achieving safe and effective correction at those levels with a laser procedure alone can be difficult. People with prescriptions in the higher range often achieve excellent results with ICL that would be impossible through corneal reshaping alone.
Very mild nearsightedness below minus 3.00 diopters usually qualifies better for LASIK or PRK. We reserve ICLs for prescriptions where they offer a clear advantage over other available options.
Astigmatism is an irregular curvature of the cornea or lens that causes blurred or distorted vision. Toric ICLs are a specialized version of the lens designed to correct astigmatism up to about 6.00 diopters alongside nearsightedness. The lens is positioned at a specific angle during surgery to align with your astigmatism axis, similar to how toric contact lenses work.
- Toric ICLs maintain stable positioning and remain accurate long term for most patients
- The lens can be rotated during a brief in-office procedure if alignment needs adjustment
- Correcting both astigmatism and nearsightedness in a single lens offers significant convenience
- Most patients with moderate to high astigmatism qualify for toric versions
ICLs are primarily designed and approved for nearsightedness correction. The space inside the eye where the ICL is placed is well suited for minus-powered lenses but poses challenges for the plus-powered lenses needed to correct farsightedness. Currently available ICL models focus on nearsighted patients because this represents the majority of people seeking correction for high prescriptions.
If you have farsightedness and want to reduce your dependence on glasses, our LASIK Surgeons may recommend alternatives such as refractive lens exchange or LASIK for lower prescriptions. These approaches generally provide better outcomes for farsighted patients.
Your prescription should remain stable for at least one year before ICL surgery. We need to feel confident that your vision will not continue changing significantly after the lens is placed. Reviewing your prescription history helps us verify this stability before moving forward.
If your prescription has shifted by more than 0.50 diopters in the past year, we may recommend waiting longer. Young adults in their early twenties sometimes experience gradual prescription changes as their eyes finish developing, so we monitor these patients carefully before approving surgery.
Eye Anatomy Requirements for ICL
Beyond your prescription, specific measurements of your eye's internal anatomy play a critical role in determining ICL candidacy. These measurements ensure the lens can be safely placed and will function well long term.
The anterior chamber is the fluid-filled space between your cornea and your iris. A minimum depth of 3.0 millimeters from the back of your cornea to your natural lens is required to safely place an ICL. Insufficient depth increases the risk of the lens contacting either the cornea or the natural lens, which could cause serious complications.
- This depth is measured precisely using specialized ultrasound or optical imaging technology
- Deeper chambers typically accommodate ICLs more comfortably
- Shallow chambers may require alternative vision correction methods
- This measurement is one of the most critical factors in determining candidacy
The endothelium is a single layer of cells lining the inside of your cornea that keeps it clear and healthy. You are born with a fixed number of these cells, and they do not regenerate. We require a healthy cell count, generally above 2,000 to 2,500 cells per square millimeter, before approving ICL surgery.
Because the ICL sits relatively close to the endothelium, we must be certain you have enough healthy cells to remain stable over the long term. We check this count using a special instrument called a specular microscope during your evaluation. Lower counts may indicate that ICL placement is not safe for your eyes.
Pupil size, especially in low-light conditions when your pupils dilate (widen), affects how you see through the ICL. Very large pupils in dim settings may cause some patients to notice glare or halos around lights if the pupil edge extends beyond the optical zone of the lens. We measure your pupils in both bright and dark conditions to assess this risk before surgery.
Most patients have pupil sizes that work well with modern ICL designs. If your pupils are exceptionally large, our LASIK Surgeons will discuss whether you might notice visual effects at night and whether that trade-off is acceptable for your lifestyle and daily activities.
LASIK requires removing a precise amount of corneal tissue, so patients must have sufficient thickness to do so safely while maintaining the eye's structural integrity. ICLs do not touch or thin the cornea at all. This makes ICL an excellent option for patients with thin corneas who are not candidates for laser surgery.
- We still measure corneal thickness as part of a complete evaluation
- Thin corneas do not disqualify you from ICL consideration
- Many patients choose ICL specifically because their corneas are too thin for laser surgery
- Corneal shape irregularities also matter less with ICL than with laser procedures
Medical Conditions That May Disqualify You
Certain existing eye conditions or general health factors can affect your safety as an ICL candidate. Our team reviews your full medical and eye health history carefully to ensure surgery is appropriate for you.
Glaucoma is a condition in which elevated pressure inside the eye or poor fluid drainage damages the optic nerve over time. A history of glaucoma or elevated eye pressure may prevent you from qualifying for ICL, because the lens sits in a space that could potentially affect fluid drainage. If drainage is already compromised or optic nerve damage exists, adding an ICL could worsen these problems.
We carefully measure your eye pressure and examine your optic nerves during the evaluation. Borderline cases may require additional testing or consultation before we can approve surgery. Well-controlled glaucoma may be considered in specific situations depending on its type and severity.
A cataract is a clouding of the natural lens inside your eye that causes blurred or hazy vision. Any significant cloudiness in your natural lens typically disqualifies you from ICL surgery, because the cataract would continue to progress after the ICL is placed and would eventually require cataract surgery anyway. Removing a cataract with an ICL already in the eye is possible but adds complexity to the procedure.
If you have early cataracts or notable age-related lens changes, refractive lens exchange may be a more appropriate choice. This procedure replaces the natural lens with an artificial one that corrects your prescription and eliminates future cataract risk. Our team assesses your lens clarity carefully during the evaluation to determine the best path forward.
Uveitis is inflammation inside the eye that can result from infection, autoimmune conditions, or other causes. A history of recurrent or chronic uveitis usually disqualifies you from ICL surgery, because the presence of the lens could trigger new inflammatory episodes or make existing inflammation harder to manage.
- A single remote episode that resolved completely may be considered on a case-by-case basis
- Any active inflammation must be fully controlled before candidacy can be discussed
- Some underlying causes of uveitis carry higher risks than others
- We may recommend consultation with a uveitis specialist if your history is complex
Severe dry eye does not directly affect ICL candidacy the way it does for LASIK candidates. LASIK can significantly worsen dry eye symptoms, but ICL typically does not. However, we still need to treat and stabilize any dry eye condition before surgery to reduce infection risk and support proper healing.
If you have moderate to severe dry eye, our team will work with you to improve your ocular surface health before proceeding. Most dry eye patients can ultimately qualify for ICL once their symptoms are well managed. For some patients, this is actually one of the advantages ICL has over laser procedures.
Pregnancy and breastfeeding can temporarily shift your vision prescription due to hormonal changes and fluid retention. We require that you are not pregnant or nursing and do not plan to become pregnant in the coming months, since prescription stability is essential for safe and effective ICL outcomes.
After you finish nursing, we recommend waiting at least three months for your hormones and vision to stabilize before your candidacy evaluation. Beginning or stopping hormonal birth control can also affect your prescription, so we prefer that your regimen has been stable for several months both before and after surgery.
Autoimmune diseases can affect healing and raise the risk of inflammation after ICL surgery. Conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis, lupus, or Sjogren syndrome require careful individual review. Well-controlled autoimmune disease may be acceptable in certain situations, but active or severe disease often disqualifies a patient from surgery.
- We may request clearance or input from your rheumatologist before proceeding
- Immunosuppressive medications can influence infection risk and healing timelines
- Eye-specific autoimmune conditions typically disqualify a patient from ICL candidacy
- Each case is assessed individually based on disease type, activity level, and overall health
What to Expect During Your Candidacy Evaluation
A complete candidacy evaluation involves much more than a standard eye exam. Our team uses a combination of clinical testing and advanced imaging technology to gather every measurement needed to make an informed recommendation for your care.
Your evaluation begins with a thorough eye exam, including a precise refraction to determine your exact prescription. We assess your visual acuity, examine all structures of your eye from front to back, and dilate your pupils to clearly view your retina, natural lens, and other internal structures. This examination identifies any diseases or structural issues that could affect your candidacy.
We look specifically for signs of glaucoma, cataracts, retinal conditions, corneal problems, and other concerns. A healthy eye examination is an essential foundation before any discussion of ICL surgery can move forward.
Several specialized tests beyond a standard exam are required. Corneal topography maps the shape and curvature of your cornea. Anterior segment imaging, using optical coherence tomography or ultrasound, measures your anterior chamber depth precisely. Specular microscopy counts your corneal endothelial cells. Together, these tests provide a complete picture of your eye anatomy.
- Pupil size is measured under both bright and dim lighting conditions
- Multiple measurements are used to calculate the correct ICL size and power for your eye
- Imaging may also assess the angle structures where fluid drains inside your eye
- These results allow us to order a lens specifically customized to your unique anatomy
Understanding what you hope to achieve helps us determine whether ICL is the right choice for your specific situation. We ask about your occupation, hobbies, sports activities, and daily visual demands. Someone who spends most of their day at a computer has different needs than someone who drives frequently at night or participates in outdoor activities.
We also discuss your expectations and whether they align with realistic outcomes. Most ICL patients achieve excellent distance vision without glasses, but many patients over 40 will still need reading glasses due to natural age-related changes in near focusing ability. Knowing your priorities helps us guide you toward the best available option.
After completing all measurements and tests, we review the findings with you in detail. We explain whether you qualify for ICL and why, or which factors may be preventing approval. If you qualify, we discuss the specific lens size and power recommended for your eyes, what results you can realistically expect, and which risks apply to your individual situation.
If you do not qualify, we explain which factors were involved and whether any alternatives might work well for you. Some disqualifying factors can be addressed over time, while others are permanent. You will leave your evaluation with a clear understanding of your options and a clear path forward.
Alternatives If You Do Not Qualify for ICL
Not qualifying for ICL does not mean you are out of options for improved vision. Several effective alternatives exist, and our team will help you identify which approach best fits your eyes, prescription, and lifestyle.
LASIK works well for low to moderate nearsightedness, farsightedness, and astigmatism when corneas are thick enough and the prescription falls within treatable ranges. The procedure reshapes the cornea using a laser after creating a thin protective flap. Most patients achieve significantly improved vision within a day or two of surgery.
If you do not qualify for ICL due to an anatomy-specific factor such as anterior chamber depth, but your prescription is within LASIK range and your corneas are adequate, LASIK may still be a strong option. Our LASIK Surgeons assess both procedures during your evaluation to determine the best fit.
PRK (photorefractive keratectomy) reshapes the cornea like LASIK but without creating a flap. The laser is applied directly to the corneal surface after removing the thin outer epithelial layer. This approach requires less corneal thickness than LASIK and may be appropriate for some patients who are not candidates for either LASIK or ICL.
- Recovery takes somewhat longer than LASIK, typically several days to a week for comfortable vision
- Final vision stabilization may take several weeks to a few months
- PRK is well suited for patients with physically active lifestyles where a LASIK flap could pose a risk
- Prescription correction limits are similar to LASIK in the moderate range
Refractive lens exchange involves removing your natural lens and replacing it with a premium artificial intraocular lens (IOL), using a procedure similar to cataract surgery. This option is well suited for patients over 45 who are beginning to lose near focusing ability, those with early cataracts, or those with very high prescriptions. Multifocal and extended depth of focus lens options can reduce or eliminate the need for reading glasses.
This procedure is more involved than ICL surgery but eliminates any future risk of cataracts, since the natural lens is removed entirely. Our team may recommend this approach if you are near the upper age limit for ICL or have early lens changes likely to progress in the coming years.
Glasses and contact lenses remain safe, effective, and reliable options for almost everyone. Modern contact lens materials provide excellent comfort and oxygen transmission even for high prescriptions. High-index eyeglass lenses can be made thin and lightweight even for strong nearsightedness.
If you do not qualify for any surgical option or simply prefer not to have surgery at this time, optimizing your traditional correction can still provide excellent vision and quality of life. Our team can help you identify the best glasses or contact lens options for your prescription and lifestyle.
Frequently Asked Questions
These answers address common points of uncertainty that come up after patients have reviewed the general candidacy information above.
Mild nearsightedness below minus 3.00 diopters typically does not meet the threshold for ICL candidacy, because simpler procedures like LASIK or PRK offer equally effective results with fewer steps and a lower overall risk profile for that prescription range. ICL is specifically reserved for cases where it provides a meaningful advantage. If your prescription is in the mild range, a laser procedure is almost always the more appropriate recommendation.
The most frequently encountered disqualifying factors are insufficient anterior chamber depth, a low corneal endothelial cell count, and pre-existing eye conditions such as glaucoma or early cataracts. Prescription instability over the past year is also a common reason we ask patients to wait before proceeding. Many of these factors can be rechecked over time, so a disqualification at one point does not necessarily mean a permanent one.
Yes, it is entirely possible for your two eyes to have different anatomical measurements or health conditions that make one eye suitable for ICL and the other less so. In these situations, our team will discuss the options available for each eye individually. We may recommend ICL for one eye and a different procedure for the other, or choose a single approach that works adequately for both eyes depending on your overall goals.
If your prescription shifts before your scheduled surgery date, we will recheck your measurements and may need to adjust the lens power ordered for your eye. After the ICL is placed, small prescription changes can sometimes be addressed with a glasses update or, in appropriate cases, a laser enhancement procedure over the lens. Significant prescription changes are uncommon once stability has been confirmed for a year or more, but individual results vary and no outcome can be guaranteed.
Yes, contact lenses can temporarily alter the shape of your cornea, which can affect the accuracy of key measurements such as corneal topography and refraction. Soft contact lens wearers are typically asked to remove their lenses for at least one to two weeks before their evaluation, while rigid or specialty lens wearers may need to go without lenses for a longer period. Our team will give you specific guidance based on the type of lenses you wear so your measurements reflect your true eye anatomy.
Schedule Your ICL Candidacy Evaluation at NewView Eye Center
A thorough candidacy evaluation is the only way to know with confidence whether ICL is the right vision correction choice for you. Our LASIK Surgeons at NewView Eye Center combine advanced diagnostic technology with personalized care to give you a clear, honest assessment of your options. If you are in Northern Virginia and ready to take the next step toward clearer vision, we encourage you to schedule a consultation with our team and find out whether your eyes, prescription, and overall health make you a strong candidate for this remarkable procedure.
What our Patients Says
Explore More
Find more information about our doctors, services, and technology that keep your eyes healthy and your vision at its best.