Highly recommend! My cataract surgery was outstanding. Of all surgeons I interviewed, she was the one who fully educated me to decide. Surgical process was efficient, organized, and results excellent.
Rene' Pettit
AREDS vs AREDS2: Which Formula Is Right for You?
Who Should Take AREDS2
These supplements are not appropriate for everyone. Only specific patients benefit from AREDS2, and taking them without a confirmed diagnosis can expose you to avoidable risks from high-dose nutrients. Your eye doctor must evaluate your AMD stage before supplementation begins.
Both formulas benefit only people with intermediate AMD, which means large drusen (yellow deposits beneath the retina) in both eyes, or large drusen in one eye with advanced AMD in the other. There is no proven benefit for early AMD or for people who have not been diagnosed with AMD. A dilated eye exam is required to confirm your stage.
Beta-carotene in the original AREDS formula significantly increased lung cancer risk in former smokers. In the original trial, lung cancer occurred in roughly twice as many participants taking beta-carotene compared to those who did not, and the vast majority of those who developed lung cancer were former smokers. If you currently smoke or have ever smoked, you must take only the AREDS2 formula. There is no safe way for smokers or former smokers to take the original formula.
If you are still taking the original AREDS formula with beta-carotene, it is worth talking to your eye doctor about switching to AREDS2. The 10-year data confirms that lutein and zeaxanthin provide equal or better AMD protection without the lung cancer risk associated with beta-carotene. Our eye doctors generally recommend AREDS2 for all qualifying patients, regardless of smoking history.
Understanding Zinc Dosage in AREDS2
One of the questions the AREDS2 trial investigated was whether the zinc dose could be safely reduced. The findings are relevant if you experience side effects or have other health concerns related to long-term zinc use.
The AREDS2 trial found no significant difference in AMD progression outcomes between the 80 mg zinc dose and the 25 mg zinc dose. Despite this, many commercial AREDS2 products still contain the higher 80 mg dose. The higher dose can cause nausea and stomach upset in some patients.
High-dose zinc can deplete copper levels in the body, which is why both AREDS formulas include copper 2 mg. If you experience side effects at the 80 mg zinc dose, ask your eye doctor about products formulated with the lower 25 mg dose. The clinical evidence supports either dose for AMD protection.
Some research suggests that high-dose zinc taken over many years may be associated with an increased risk of prostate cancer. Men starting AREDS2 supplements, particularly those with other prostate cancer risk factors, should discuss this concern with their physician. Your overall health picture matters when choosing the right dose.
What AREDS2 Cannot Do
It is important to have realistic expectations about what these supplements can and cannot accomplish. Understanding their limits helps you stay engaged in the full scope of your AMD care.
Clinical trial data from both AREDS and AREDS2 showed no benefit in people with early AMD or no AMD. These are not general eye health vitamins. Taking them without the correct diagnosis provides no protection and exposes you to the risks that come with high-dose nutrients.
Neither formula cures AMD or restores vision that has already been lost. Their role is to slow progression from intermediate to advanced AMD. Supplements are a protective measure, not a treatment for existing vision loss.
AREDS2 supplements do not replace regular dilated eye exams, anti-VEGF injections for wet AMD (a form of advanced AMD treated with medications injected into the eye), or other prescribed therapies. Patients taking AREDS2 still need consistent monitoring, and additional treatments may be needed as AMD progresses over time.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are answers to questions we hear often from patients managing AMD with nutritional supplements.
Standard multivitamins do not contain the specific nutrient doses tested in the AREDS2 trial and cannot substitute for the clinical formula. The differences in concentration are significant enough that a typical multivitamin would not provide the same level of AMD protection. Ask your eye doctor to recommend a product that matches the exact AREDS2 formulation.
The AREDS2 formula is now recommended for all patients, including non-smokers. Lutein and zeaxanthin perform as well as or better than beta-carotene for AMD protection, with no lung cancer risk. There is no clinical advantage to choosing the original formula over AREDS2, so most eye doctors no longer recommend it.
AREDS2 supplements are available over the counter at most pharmacies without a prescription. However, you should only begin taking them after your eye doctor has confirmed that your AMD stage qualifies. Always check the product label carefully to ensure the formulation matches the AREDS2 nutrient doses, since not all eye vitamin products on the shelf meet that standard.
Yes, interactions are possible. High-dose vitamin E in AREDS2 can interact with blood thinners such as warfarin, and high-dose zinc can interfere with the absorption of certain antibiotics. Bring a complete list of your medications and supplements to every eye appointment so your eye doctor and pharmacist can review them together. Do not start AREDS2 without completing this step if you take prescription medications regularly.
The AREDS2 trial found no statistically significant difference in AMD outcomes between the 80 mg and 25 mg zinc doses. If you are tolerating the higher dose without side effects, there is no urgent reason to switch. If stomach upset or nausea is a concern, the lower-dose option is a clinically supported alternative worth discussing with your eye doctor.
Most patients with intermediate AMD take AREDS2 supplements on a long-term basis. The 10-year follow-up data shows that the benefit is sustained over a decade of consistent use. Your eye doctor will guide you based on how your AMD is progressing and whether any changes to your overall health affect the appropriateness of continuing supplementation.
Talk to Our Team About Your AMD Care
At NewView Eye Center, our eye doctors are here to help you navigate every aspect of your AMD management, including which supplement formula is right for your specific situation. We take the time to review your diagnosis, your health history, and your medications before making any recommendation. If you have questions about AREDS2 or your current AMD care plan, we invite you to schedule an appointment at one of our two Northern Virginia locations. Your vision is worth the conversation.
What our Patients Says
Explore More
Find more information about our doctors, services, and technology that keep your eyes healthy and your vision at its best.
Macular Degeneration Prevention
AMD Treatment: Options for Dry and Wet Macular Degeneration
When AMD Becomes Urgent: Sudden Distortion and Vision Changes
Dry AMD and Wet AMD: Understanding Both Forms of Macular Degeneration
Wet AMD: What You Need to Know About Treatment and Vision Protection
AREDS2 Vitamins and Supplements for Age-Related Macular Degeneration